Which Is The Most Likely Purpose Of The Dashes In “That I Did Always Love”?

which is the most likely purpose of the dashes in "that i did always love"?
Contents

The most likely purpose of the dashes in “That I did always love” is to create pauses that slow the reader down and put emphasis on key words and ideas.

“That I did always love” is a short love poem by Emily Dickinson. In versions based on her manuscripts, dashes break up the lines, so each phrase lands with extra weight.

About the Poem

The poem has three short stanzas. The speaker offers “proof” that she has always loved and always will. She argues that love is life, and life has immortality.

In the last stanza, the speaker asks whether the listener still doubts her. If so, she has nothing left to show “But Calvary,” a reference to the place of Jesus’s crucifixion and a symbol of suffering.

Why Dickinson Used Dashes

The Emily Dickinson Museum notes that Dickinson most often punctuated her poems with dashes. Many writers of her time used the dash, but she may have been the only poet to depend on it.

The museum also says she may have meant the dashes to mark pauses when a poem is read aloud. That is why “to create a pause” or “to emphasize” is usually the best answer on a quiz.

In this poem, the pauses do several jobs:

  • Emphasis: a pause before or after a word, like “Calvary,” makes it stand out.
  • Breaks in thought: the speaker seems to stop and gather herself, as if arguing her case step by step.
  • Rhythm: the short lines and dashes slow the pace, which suits a serious, emotional declaration.

Why Some Versions Have No Dashes

If your copy of the poem has commas and periods instead of dashes, you may be reading an early printed edition. According to the Academy of American Poets, Dickinson’s first editors replaced her dashes with regular punctuation such as commas and periods.

The early printed version on Project Gutenberg, titled “Proof,” uses commas and periods throughout. Modern editions based on her manuscripts keep the dashes.

How to Answer Questions About Dashes

When a question asks for the purpose of a dash in a poem or passage, check these clues:

  1. Is there a pause or shift? A dash often signals an interruption, a sudden turn, or a moment of hesitation.
  2. Is a word set apart? A word framed by dashes usually carries emphasis.
  3. Is extra information added? In prose, a pair of dashes can set off a parenthetical phrase, like a stronger pair of commas.

For “That I did always love,” the first two clues apply. The dashes create pauses that stress the speaker’s strong feelings.

Conclusion

The dashes in “That I did always love” most likely create pauses that emphasize key words and ideas. They slow the reader down and give the speaker’s declaration of love extra force.

Sources